Meet the Team | First Insurance Group

At our firm, we have the client—and only the client—in mind.

Our reasons for becoming insurance professionals are deeply personal. We repeatedly saw friends and family struggling to find the coverage they needed. We are confident that with our understanding of the insurance space, we can help people better prepare for the future. After years in the business, we have developed a reputation for educating individuals in an easy-to-understand manner, so they can easily grasp personal insurance concepts. Above all else, we feel a commitment to our community.

Over the years, we have found that a team approach can be an effective method of helping clients with a wide variety of needs, as they navigate the complex world of insurance. We invite you to discover and experience the benefits of a diverse team with differing educational interests, experiences, and strategies.

One-size-fits-all just doesn't apply to insurance, which is why every client gets our undivided attention. We take a proactive approach when helping you develop a strategy to address all of your insurance needs. We recognize that everyone encounters challenges along the way and strive to anticipate those situations as they occur. Our only goal is to keep you and your loved ones protected with the policies you need. We invite you to check out all the material on our website. If something prompts a question, please send us a quick email or call our office. We look forward to speaking with you.

Principle

First Insurance Group - Bloomington

Producers

Scott Peyton

Paul Peach

Commercial Lines

Anna Babbs

Customer Care Agent

Barb Hash

Customer Care Agent

Casey White

Customer Care Agent

Heidi Darling

Customer Care Agent

Jeanie Glassco

Customer Care Agent

Jenna Kingston

Customer Care Agent

Kathy Carter

Customer Care Agent

Donna Johnson

Customer Care Agent

Ellie Siemon

Customer Support

Personal Lines

Duran Kincaid

Customer Support

Janice Fleener

Customer Care Agent

Malinda Graham

Customer Support

Jacque Osborne

Customer Care Agent

Robert Muñoz

Customer Care Agent

Karen Muñoz

Support

Kim Bates

Marketing

Twyla Martin

Accounting

Marcia Manzo

Accounting

Jan Sansone

Accounting

Chris Hunt

Director of Finance/Controller

Sheryl Morse

Claims Administrator

Employee Benefits

Jeff Grossnickle

Employee Benefits

Kim Sims

Employee Benefits | HR

Insurance Services - Spencer

Amanda Huntington

Customer Care Agent

Carmen Wall

Customer Care Agent

Larken Seymour

Customer Care Agent

Nick McCollum

Producer

Stephanie Hoadley

Customer Care Agent

Susan Anderson

Customer Care Agent

Franklin Insurance Agency - Franklin

Beverly Prior

Customer Care Agent

Regan Hill

Customer Support

Stephen Brown

Producer

Victoria McQueen

Customer Care Agent

J&S Farmers - Franklin

Nick McCollum

Producer

Jennifer Kean

Customer Care Agent

Maggie Dixion

Customer Care Agent

Austin Insurance Agency - Nashville

Martha Bartlett

Customer Support

Jennifer Sanders

Customer Care Agent

1st Security Insurance - Bloomfield

John Mensch

Producer

Ashley Thomas

Customer Care Agent

Bailee Pierce

Customer Care Agent

1st Security Insurance - Worthington

1st Security Insurance - Linton

Mark Babbs

Producer

Kathleen Ferree

Customer Care Agent

Client Centered

Whether you are looking for help protecting your family, your home, or your assets, our personalized service focuses on your needs, wants, and long-term goals.

Our team has years of experience in the insurance industry. We can help you address your needs of today and for many years to come. We look forward to working with you.

Contact Us