Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team

Meet Our Team

Get to know the team that’s here to help with your insurance needs.

View our list of team members by office.

First Insurance Group Franklin Insurance Agency Insurance Services Inc J&S Farmers Austin Insurance Agency 1st Security Insurance Tucker Insurance Group

Principles

Tony Brown

Tony Brown
Principle – First Insurance Group

812-355-2584

Scott Peyton

Scott Peyton
Principle - First Insurance Group

812-457-3056

Kathy Carter CIC

Kathy Carter CIC
Principle - First Insurance Group

812-355-4604

Nick McCollum

Nick McCollum
Principle - Insurance Services Inc

812-208-2457

Frank Eberle CIC

Frank Eberle CIC
Principle - First Insurance Group

812-355-2587

Lance Eberle, CIC, CRM

Lance Eberle, CIC, CRM
Principle - First Insurance Group

812-355-4601

Garth Goodlett, CIC

Garth Goodlett, CIC
Principle - First Insurance Group

812-355-2581

John Auld

John Auld
Principle - Franklin Insurance Agency

317-736-8277

Duane Smith, AFIS

Duane Smith, AFIS
Principle - J&S Farmers Insurance

317-736-6744

Wally DeFord, CIC

Wally DeFord, CIC
Principle - Insurance Services Inc

812-829-4853

Craig Austin

Craig Austin
Principle - Austin Insurance Agency

812-988-6642

First Insurance Group - Bloomington

Personal

Duran Kincaid

Duran Kincaid
Customer Support

Jacque Osborne

Jacque Osborne
Customer Care Agent

Robert Muñoz

Robert Muñoz
Customer Care Agent

Abbie Sherfick

Abbie Sherfick
Customer Care Agent

Ava Sipes
Personal Lines Support

Commercial

Lakelin Teague

Lakelin Teague
Customer Care Agent

Anastacia Clampitt

Anastacia Clampitt
Commercial Lines Support

Anna Babbs

Anna Babbs
Customer Care Agent

Barb Eads

Barb Eads
Customer Support

Casey White

Casey White
Customer Care Agent

Heidi Darling

Heidi Darling
Customer Care Agent

Jeanie Glassco

Jeanie Glassco
Customer Care Agent

Jenna Kingston

Jenna Kingston
Commercial Training and Communication Specialist

Donna Johnson

Donna Johnson
Customer Care Agent

Employee Benefits

Jeff Grossnickle, LITCF, PPACA

Jeff Grossnickle, LITCF, PPACA
Employee Benefits

Juliet Smith

Juliet Smith
Employee Benefits / HR

Support Staff

Kevin Perkins

Kevin Perkins
Accounting

Katie Cassidy

Katie Cassidy
Front Desk Coordinator

Shannon Weiss

Shannon Weiss
Accounting Coordinator

Kim Bates, CIC

Kim Bates, CIC
Marketing

Chris Hunt

Chris Hunt
Director of Finance/Controller

Sheryl Morse

Sheryl Morse
Claims Administrator

Franklin Insurance Agency - Franklin Location

John Auld

John Auld
Principle – Franklin Insurance Agency

317-736-8277

Duane Smith, AFIS

Duane Smith, AFIS
Principle - J&S Farmers Insurance

317-736-6744

Stephen Brown

Stephen Brown
Producer

317-441-7406

Tasha Gill

Tasha Gill
Customer Care Agent

Katie Wheeler

Katie Wheeler
Producer

317-736-8277

Jennifer Kean

Jennifer Kean
Customer Care Agent

Maggie Dixion

Maggie Dixion
Customer Care Agent

Dianna Phelps
Customer Care Agent

Regan Hill

Regan Hill
Support

Beverly Prior

Beverly Prior
Commercial Care Agent

Victoria McQueen

Victoria McQueen
Personal Care Agent

Insurance Services Inc. - Spencer Location

Stephanie Hoadley

Stephanie Hoadley
Customer Care Agent

Christina Mobley

Christina Mobley
Front Desk Coordinator

Wally DeFord, CIC

Wally DeFord, CIC
Principle – Insurance Services Inc

812-829-4853

Karen Muñoz

Karen Muñoz
Customer Care Agent

Carmen Wall

Carmen Wall
Customer Care Agent

J&S Farmers - Franklin Location

Jennifer Kean

Jennifer Kean
Customer Care Agent

Maggie Dixion

Maggie Dixion
Customer Care Agent

Austin Insurance Agency - Nashville Location

Craig Austin

Craig Austin
Principle – Austin Insurance Agency

812-988-6642

Martha Bartlett

Martha Bartlett
Customer Support

Jennifer Sanders

Jennifer Sanders
Customer Care Agent

Bobby Fox

Bobby Fox
Customer Care Agent

1st Security Insurance - Bloomfield Location

Addalynn Spinnie

Addalynn Spinnie
Personal Lines Assistant

Ashley Thomas

Ashley Thomas
Customer Care Agent

Mark Babbs

Mark Babbs
Producer

812-847-4077

Ariana Walker

Ariana Walker
Customer Care Agent

Tucker Insurance Group - Orleans Location

Carmen Alston

Carmen Alston
Customer Care Agent

Tracy Tucker

Tracy Tucker
Producer

812-521-1629

Tyler Atchison

Tyler Atchison
Producer

812-909-9595

Amanda Tucker

Amanda Tucker
Producer

Brayton Clipp

Brayton Clipp
Customer Care Agent

Prefer to speak with someone from First Insurance Group?
Contact us directly.