Contact Us

First Insurance Group, Inc.
1405 N. College Ave.
Bloomington, IN  47404
(812) 331-3230
(812) 331-3233
(800) 880-0213

Accounting  
Jan Sansone (812) 355-2593
Marcia Manzo (812) 355-2579
   
Claims  
Sharon Sears (812) 355-2588
   
Commercial Lines  
Anna Babbs (812) 355-4607
Linda Potts (812) 355-2580
Heidi Darling (812) 355-4609
Brittany Hash

(812) 355-4606

Jessica Gleason (812) 355-4605
Kathy Carter (812) 355-4604
Kim Bates (812) 355-4603
Debbie Kipper (812) 355-2598
Pat Fisher

(812) 355-4610

Dottie Martin

(812) 355-2567 

Health & Life  
Jeffrey Grossnickle (812) 355-2595
Kim Sims (812) 355-2592
   
Personal Lines  
Colleen Perry (812) 355-2599
Janice Fleener (812) 355-2577
Wendy Hall (812) 355-2583
Jacque Osborne (812) 355-2589
   
Producers  
Frank Eberle - Partner (812) 355-2587
Lance Eberle - Partner (812) 355-4601
Mike Gleason - Partner (812) 355-4612
Ron Cheatham - Partner (812) 355-4600
Garth Goodlett - Partner (812) 355-2581
Larry Decker (812) 355-2594
Mark Babbs (812) 355-4611
Brian Smith (502) 641-4587 
Jay Carter (812) 355-2576
Scott Peyton (812) 457-3056 
Tony Brown (812) 355-2584